American Pie star Jason Biggs has asked girlfriend/ actress Jenny Mollen to marry him. She joked that he’d asked her repeatedly, and he admitted to having asked her the first night they met. First night?

Biggs will be in three films this year: Over Her Dead Body (which opens tomorrow, Feb 1st), My Best Friend’s Girl, and Lower Learning.

Mollen is also in My Best Friend’s Girl, and will be in Off the Ledge.